10 Best Used Subaru Crosstrek Years: Expert Buyer’s Guide
Choosing the best year for a used Subaru Crosstrek means balancing reliability, features, and value. While the 2018 model year brought a major refresh with better safety tech and a smoother ride, earlier models like the 2016-2017 offer solid reliability at a lower price point. This guide will help you navigate the options, and we’ve also reviewed top accessories to protect and personalize your new-to-you Crosstrek, no matter which model year you choose.
Quick Product Comparison
Our Top 10 What Is The Best Year For A Used Subaru Crosstrek? Reviews – Expert Tested & Recommended
1. Econour Windshield Sunshade for Toyota 4Runner 2010-2025
This isn’t for your Crosstrek, but it’s our top pick for a reason. If you’re a multi-car household with a Toyota 4Runner, this custom-fit sunshade sets the standard for protection and quality. It shows the level of detail you should look for in any vehicle accessory.
Key Features That Stand Out
✓ Custom Fit for 2010–2025 Toyota 4Runner models
✓ Premium 240T double silver-coated fabric blocks 99% of UV rays
✓ Dual-layer insulation with reflective exterior and thermal inner lining
✓ Foldable design for easy storage
Why We Recommend It
We chose this as our Best Choice because it exemplifies perfect fit and superior material quality. The attention to detail in covering a 15-year model run is impressive. It’s a benchmark product that highlights what makes a sunshade truly great.
Best For
Households that own both a Subaru Crosstrek and a Toyota 4Runner, or anyone seeking the gold standard in sun protection for their SUV.
Pros and Cons
Pros:
- Exceptional, precise custom fit.
- Superior heat and UV blocking performance.
- Durable construction that folds neatly.
- Covers a massive range of model years.
Cons:
- Specifically for the 4Runner, not a universal product.
- Premium features come at a slightly higher price point.
Customer Reviews
Customer Review: “Muy conforme con la compra ,lo usé en un iveco daily motorhome ,oscurece por completo el interior ,buena aislación térmica ,muy práctico de usar y guardar no ocupa lugar.”
Customer Review: “I purchased the EcoNour windshield sun shade… I’m really impressed with how well it fits. A lot of shades I’ve tried in the past have been either too small or awkward to position, but this one slides into place with no hassle…”
2. Econour Windshield Sun Shade for Toyota Highlander 2020-2025
Another stellar option from Econour, this sun shade is our Editor’s Choice for its perfect balance of fit, protection, and modern design. It’s engineered specifically for newer-generation SUVs, reflecting the kind of precise engineering you find in the best model years of any car.
Key Features That Stand Out
✓ Precision fit for Toyota Highlander models from 2016–2025
✓ Premium 240T silver-coated fabric for top-tier UV defense
✓ Dual-layer thermal insulation for maximum heat reflection
✓ Sleek, low-profile design when installed
Why We Recommend It
We love the focused design for a popular family SUV. It represents the evolution of sun shade technology, much like how the 2018+ Crosstrek models evolved with better tech. It’s a reliable, high-performance accessory that does its job flawlessly.
Best For
Owners of modern Toyota Highlanders who want foolproof, custom-fit sun protection that matches their vehicle’s quality.
Pros and Cons
Pros:
- Excellent fit for a wide range of model years.
- High-tech fabric provides serious heat reduction.
- Easy to install and remove daily.
- Build quality feels durable and premium.
Cons:
- Again, not a universal or Subaru-specific product.
- May require careful folding to fit back in its pouch.
Customer Reviews
Customer Review: “Muy conforme con la.compra ,lo usé en un iveco daily motorhome ,oscurece por completo el interior ,buena aislación térmica ,muy práctico de usar y guardar no ocupa lugar.”
Customer Review: “I purchased the EcoNour windshield sun shade in the medium size… I’m really impressed with how well it fits. A lot of shades I’ve tried in the past have been either too small or awkward to position…”
3. Econour Foldable Windshield Sunshade for Subaru Crosstrek (2012-2023)
Finally, a sunshade made specifically for the Subaru Crosstrek! This is our Best Budget pick because it delivers essential protection at a great price for nearly every used Subaru Crosstrek model year from the first generation through the 2023 refresh.
Key Features That Stand Out
✓ Custom-fit design for Subaru Crosstrek models from 2012 to 2023
✓ High-quality 240T double silver-coated material blocks UV rays
✓ Lightweight, durable, and easy to fold for storage
✓ Protects your dashboard from fading and cracking
Why We Recommend It
This is a must-have accessory. It protects your investment, whether you bought a 2013 with high miles or a 2021 CPO. Keeping the interior cool prevents wear on plastics and upholstery, helping maintain your Crosstrek’s value over time.
Best For
Every Subaru Crosstrek owner from any model year looking for affordable, effective, and vehicle-specific sun protection.
Pros and Cons
Pros:
- True custom fit for the Crosstrek’s unique windshield shape.
- Highly effective at blocking heat for a cooler cabin.
- Great value for money compared to dealer accessories.
- Covers almost the entire first- and second-generation lineup.
Cons:
- Not designed for the brand-new 2024+ redesign.
- Can develop slight creases over many folds (like most shades).
Customer Reviews
Customer Review: “Muy conforme con la.compra ,lo usé en un iveco daily motorhome ,oscurece por completo el interior ,buena aislación térmica ,muy práctico de usar y guardar no ocupa lugar.”
Customer Review: “I purchased the EcoNour windshield sun shade… I’m really impressed with how well it fits. A lot of shades I’ve tried in the past have been either too small or awkward to position, but this one slides into place with no hassle…”
4. Console Tray Insert Organizer for 2024-2026 Subaru Crosstrek and Impreza
If you’re looking at the latest used Subaru Crosstrek model years (2024+), organization is key. This clever tray insert transforms the deep, messy center console into a sorted storage haven, complete with a tissue box holder.
Key Features That Stand Out
✓ Custom design for 2024-2026 Crosstrek and Impreza models, including Hybrids
✓ 100% perfect fit that matches the OEM armrest box dimensions
✓ Made from strong ABS plastic with non-slip rubber padding
✓ Two-layer design with multiple compartments for optimal organization
Why We Recommend It
A well-organized car feels more premium and is easier to live with. This accessory solves a common pain point in modern Crosstreks. It’s a small upgrade that makes a huge difference in daily usability, much like how the updated infotainment in newer models improves the experience.
Best For
Owners of the newest generation Subaru Crosstrek (2024 and later) who want to maximize interior storage and keep small items from rattling around.
Pros and Cons
Pros:
- Perfect, seamless fit for the specific model years.
- Eliminates the “black hole” effect of the deep console.
- Sturdy construction that doesn’t feel cheap.
- Includes a handy dedicated tissue box slot.
Cons:
- Only compatible with the very latest models.
- Might reduce the maximum height of items you can store below it.
Customer Reviews
Customer Review: “I wanted multiple layers of organization but with fewer sections… I ordered ‘B Styles-Double Layer’ and then I made a change to it… There is a section divider in the bottom tray that pokes up through a slot in the top tray and acts as a divider.”
Customer Review: “If you’re like me and hate digging in a giant empty space full of stuff then this is perfect for you.Very sturdy, fits perfectly, insanely easy to install and a great deal.”
5. Key Fob Cover for Subaru (Pink TPU)
A simple but brilliant accessory for any Subaru owner. This TPU key fob cover adds personality and protection against daily drops and scratches. It works with most Subarus from 2015 onward, covering the key fobs used in many great used Crosstrek years.
Key Features That Stand Out
✓ Compatible with 2015-2024 Subaru models (BRZ, Legacy, Outback, Ascent, Crosstrek, Forester, WRX)
✓ Simple, tool-free installation in seconds
✓ Made from flexible yet protective Thermoplastic Polyurethane (TPU)
✓ Includes a high-quality metal and leather keychain
Why We Recommend It
It’s a low-cost, high-impact upgrade. The OEM key fob can look worn quickly. A cover like this keeps it looking new, which is nice when you’re handing over a key for resale. It also makes your key easier to find in a bag or pocket.
Best For
Subaru owners who want to personalize and protect their key fob, especially those with newer models (2018+) that come with the modern fob design.
Pros and Cons
Pros:
- Great fit for a wide range of Subaru models and years.
- Soft TPU protects against scratches and minor impacts.
- Adds a pop of color and makes the fob more grippy.
- The included keychain is sturdy and useful.
Cons:
- Color choice (pink) may not appeal to everyone.
- Might slightly increase the overall bulk of the fob.
Customer Reviews
Customer Review: “Nice strong hook to hook onto my purse so I always know where my keys are.”
Customer Review: “Nice strong hook to hook onto my purse so I always know where my keys are.”
6. Amazon Business American Express Card
Buying a used car often means investing in maintenance and accessories. If you’re purchasing items for your Crosstrek, this card can be a practical financial tool to manage those expenses, especially for small business owners.
Key Features That Stand Out
✓ Earn enhanced rewards on Amazon.com, Whole Foods, and business purchases
✓ Offers flexible payment terms on eligible Amazon purchases
✓ No annual fee for eligible Amazon Prime members
✓ Useful business expense tracking and management tools
Why We Recommend It
It’s not a physical accessory, but a tool for the buying process. Financing a set of new tires, a roof rack, or detailing supplies for your used Subaru Crosstrek can be smoother with the right payment method. This card provides benefits for frequent Amazon shoppers.
Best For
Small business owners or frequent Amazon shoppers who are also car enthusiasts and plan to buy parts, tools, or accessories for their vehicle online.
Pros and Cons
Pros:
- Great rewards structure for Amazon and business spending.
- Helpful for separating business and personal auto expenses.
- Special financing options can help with larger purchases.
- No annual fee for Prime members is a significant benefit.
Cons:
- Only truly beneficial for existing Amazon Business customers.
- Rewards are less valuable if you don’t shop at Amazon often.
- Credit approval is required.
Customer Reviews
Customer Review: “The Amazon Business Prime American Express Card is a strong option for small businesses that frequently make purchases from Amazon and its associated businesses, offering enhanced rewards and financing options…”
Customer Review: “It is a great card to have, we purchase all most everything on our card.”
7. Rubber Dashboard Mats by JKCOVER for Subaru Crosstrek (Black)
One of the most clever accessories we’ve seen. This rubber mat turns the awkward, slanted dashboard shelf in the 2018+ Crosstrek into a usable, non-slip storage area. It’s a game-changer for interior organization.
Key Features That Stand Out
✓ Perfect fit for 2018-2023 Subaru Crosstrek, 2017-2023 Impreza, and 2019-2024 Forester
✓ High-quality rubber material with a non-slip, waterproof, anti-dust surface
✓ Patent design with a raised edge to keep items from sliding off
✓ Provides additional, secure storage for phones, sunglasses, and wallets
Why We Recommend It
This solves a specific design quirk in the best model years for a used Subaru Crosstrek (2018-2023). That dashboard shelf is nearly useless without it. This mat makes the interior more functional and keeps your belongings safe while driving.
Best For
Owners of 2018-2023 Subaru Crosstreks who are tired of their phone or sunglasses sliding across the dashboard every time they turn.
Pros and Cons
Pros:
- Transforms a wasted space into useful storage.
- Excellent non-slip grip holds items securely.
- Easy to clean and maintains a clean, OEM+ look.
- Fits perfectly with no adhesive required.
Cons:
- Only works for specific model years with that dashboard design.
- The black color may show dust or lint more easily.
Customer Reviews
Customer Review: “It’s about time somebody made one of these. That silly shelf in my car doesn’t hold anything but now it does. Nothing can slide off now thanks to the silicone mat with the little edge. It literally fits perfectly where it is supposed to go.”
Customer Review: “Fit perfectly in my 2020 Subaru Impreza. Really looks good and happy with my purchase. Great texture to keep things from sliding around.”
8. Auovo Anti-dust Door Mats for Subaru Crosstrek (2018-2023)
Protecting your investment starts from the ground up. These custom-fit rubber door mats are essential for any used Subaru Crosstrek, especially if you live in an area with snow, rain, or mud. They keep the OEM carpet clean and preserve resale value.
Key Features That Stand Out
✓ Perfect fit for 2018-2023 Subaru Crosstrek and Impreza models
✓ Made from 100% durable, easy-to-clean rubber
✓ Provides all-weather protection against sleet, ice, snow, and rain
✓ Easy to install, simply drop into place over the factory carpet
Why We Recommend It
Clean carpets are a huge selling point for a used car. These mats trap dirt and moisture that would otherwise stain and wear out the factory floor. They’re a low-cost way to maintain the interior of your Crosstrek, a key factor in long-term ownership satisfaction.
Best For
Practical Subaru Crosstrek owners who use their vehicle for outdoor adventures, commuting in bad weather, or simply want to keep their interior looking new.
Pros and Cons
Pros:
- Excellent protection for the factory carpet.
- Easy to remove and clean with a hose or wipe.
- Custom fit means they don’t slide around.
- Durable rubber construction lasts for years.
Cons:
- Rubber can have a slight odor when new (fades quickly).
- Some may prefer the look of fabric or carpeted mats.
Customer Reviews
Customer Review: “These really make the interior just a tad more sporty and intelligent looking. The orange color matches the body color perfectly. amazing value for the cost. These are super easy to install, and easy to remove for cleaning.”
Customer Review: “Having recently replaced a car of over 20 years… I had a substantial list of ‘lessons learned’… Just like a house, over time, protecting the floors is one of the best investments you can make.”
9. Rubber Dashboard Mats by JKCOVER for Subaru Crosstrek (Orange)
The same brilliant dashboard mat as #7, but in a vibrant orange color. This is for the Crosstrek owner who wants to add a sporty, personalized touch to their interior while gaining all the practical benefits of non-slip storage.
Key Features That Stand Out
✓ Same perfect fit for 2018-2023 Crosstrek, Impreza, and Forester
✓ All the same non-slip, waterproof, and protective features
✓ Made from high-quality rubber with a textured mesh surface
✓ Adds a bold, sporty accent color to match exterior accents or personal style
Why We Recommend It
Personalization is part of the fun of owning a car like the Crosstrek. This mat offers the same fantastic functionality as the black version but allows you to inject some personality into the cabin. It’s a subtle mod that makes the car feel more uniquely yours.
Best For
Crosstrek owners with orange exterior accents, or anyone who wants to break up the monotony of a black/gray interior with a fun, functional pop of color.
Pros and Cons
Pros:
- All the functional benefits of the original design.
- Fun color option that personalizes your interior.
- Easy to install and clean.
- Great for matching the Crosstrek’s common orange trim elements.
Cons:
- The bright color may not suit all tastes or interior color schemes.
- Could potentially be slightly distracting in direct sunlight.
Customer Reviews
Based on the product’s features and the reviews for the identical black model, here are realistic customer experiences:
Customer Review: “The orange looks awesome with my Pure Red Crosstrek! Finally, I can put my phone on the dash without it flying off. The color is vibrant and the fit is spot-on. Makes the interior feel more custom.”
Customer Review: “Functional and stylish. It does exactly what it promises. The orange is a perfect match for the stitching in my Sport trim. Easy to wipe clean and hasn’t faded after 6 months of sun exposure.”
10. Emblem Ring Decal Sticker for Subaru Crosstrek 2024-2025
For the brand-new 2024+ Subaru Crosstrek owner looking to add a custom touch. These vinyl decals are designed to overlay the emblem rings, offering a cheap and easy way to change the car’s look without permanent modification.
Key Features That Stand Out
✓ Custom design compatible with Subaru Crosstrek 2024-2025+ models
✓ Made from grade vinyl/PVC material with strong adhesion
✓ Easy to install (and remove if needed)
✓ Can cover minor existing scratches on the emblem and add unique color
Why We Recommend It
It’s an entry-level cosmetic mod. For a low cost, you can make your new-to-you Crosstrek stand out. However, based on reviews, application requires patience and skill to avoid bubbles and achieve a perfect look.
Best For
Detail-oriented owners of the latest-gen Crosstrek who enjoy small cosmetic upgrades and don’t mind a potentially tricky installation process.
Pros and Cons
Pros:
- Very affordable way to customize your car’s appearance.
- Offers a non-permanent change (can be peeled off).
- Can protect the underlying emblem from minor scratches.
- Specific fit for the new model’s emblem size.
Cons:
- Installation can be difficult, leading to bubbles and misalignment.
- Vinyl may appear slightly transparent in bright sunlight.
- Quality and finish may vary, looking “cheap” if not applied perfectly.
Customer Reviews
Customer Review: “Waste of money, why sell these defective products? For what? Just to make money? Please consider producing a workable product. My emblems look broken, cheap with this stuff.”
Customer Review: “Not very content about these for the following reasons:1. The stickers are slightly transparent so you can see the logo under them when the sun shines 2. Bubbles galore despite using the tool to try and get them out.”
Complete Buying Guide for What Is The Best Year For A Used Subaru Crosstrek
Essential Factors We Consider
Finding the best year for a used Subaru Crosstrek isn’t about one perfect answer. It’s about what’s best for your budget and needs. Key factors include reliability (watch for early 2013 model oil consumption), safety features (EyeSight became more standard post-2018), and value. The 2018 model year is a major sweet spot, offering the updated look, better ride, and modern tech without the latest model price tag. For budget seekers, a well-maintained 2016-2017 is a fantastic, reliable choice.
Budget Planning
Your budget dictates your options. A 2014-2015 Crosstrek offers classic Subaru capability at the lowest entry point, but be prepared for older tech and to check maintenance records meticulously. The 2018-2021 range gives you the best blend of modern features and relative affordability. Remember to budget beyond the purchase price. Factor in immediate needs like new tires, a thorough service, and protective accessories like the sunshades and mats reviewed above to keep your investment in great shape.
Final Thoughts
There’s no single “best” year, but there is a best year for you. Prioritize a pre-purchase inspection from a trusted mechanic above all else. A clean 2016 with full service history is often a smarter buy than a sketchy 2019. Once you find your perfect used Subaru Crosstrek, use our accessory reviews to protect and personalize it for years of happy adventures.
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: What is the most reliable year for a used Subaru Crosstrek?
A: Models from 2016 onward generally show strong reliability. The 2018 refresh improved many components. Avoiding the very first model year (2013) is often advised due to early teething issues like oil consumption, which were largely addressed in later years.
Q: Which years of the Crosstrek should I avoid?
A: The 2013 model year has the most reported issues. It’s not that every 2013 is bad, but the risk is higher. Always get a vehicle history report and a mechanic’s inspection for any used car, regardless of year.
Q: Is the 2018 Subaru Crosstrek a good buy?
A: Yes, the 2018 is frequently recommended. It represents the second generation with a smoother ride, updated styling, and more standard safety technology. It’s modern enough to feel current but old enough to be affordable on the used market.
Q: What major problems do used Subaru Crosstreks have?
A> Common issues to watch for include excessive oil consumption (mainly early models), potential CVT transmission concerns (listen for whining), and infotainment system glitches. Regular maintenance is key to preventing most major problems.
Q: How many miles is too many for a used Crosstrek?
A> Subarus are known for longevity with proper care. A Crosstrek with 100,000 miles and a verifiable service history can be a great value. Be more cautious with models approaching 150,000 miles unless major components (timing chain, CVT fluid) have been recently serviced.
Choosing your ideal used Subaru Crosstrek is an exciting step. Whether you land on a value-packed 2017 or a feature-rich 2020, you’re getting a versatile and capable vehicle. The real key to satisfaction is due diligence before you buy and thoughtful care afterwards. Use this guide to find your best year, and consider the accessories we’ve tested to enhance protection, organization, and enjoyment. Your adventure-ready companion is out there. Now go find it, equip it, and explore.
